Myth Blaster – Was Jesse James Assassinated or Die of Old Age?

JesseJames_WantedPoster This Myth Blaster concerns an historical figure, and being an avid historical fan of the American Old West, I couldn’t resist publishing this researched material. The idea of writing about Jesse and the James-Younger Gang came about when I had published the Historical Footnotes of September 7th that concerns the Northfield, Minnesota bank robbery that occurred on that day in 1876. The American Old West is filled with myths, legends, true stories that occurred between the years of 1865 to 1890. It was a period of Western US settlement called the “frontier” or the period that involved conflict between cowboys, Indians, businessmen, cattlemen, the US government, US Marshals, town sheriffs, and outlaws of the period in American history. Idealized or rather fictionalized more often than not in the form of “Dime Novels” – it was a time in American history when lawlessness sometimes occurred in territories that later became states where the law was far and few between towns. Violent range wars occurred between settlers who went west to find a new life and obtain land for farms and ranches they dreamed of having in the new land. Famous range wars include the Pleasant Valley War, Lincoln County War, and the Johnson Country Range War. Corrupt justice systems often played part in these events.

I will begin with the traditional historical background of Jesse James that includes his brother, Frank James, and the others who were involved with him. Then I will present the controversial legend that Jesse James was not assassinated, but died instead in an “old folks home” for Confederate veterans – a controversy that has been going on since it hit the news in the 1950s beginning with the Wikipedia entry …

JesseJames-01 Jesse Woodson James (September 5, 1847 to April 3, 1882) … was born in Clay County, Missouri, near the site of present day Kearney. As an adult Jesse was of medium height, of slender but solid build, with a bearded, narrow face, and prominent blue eyes. Until his later years, when he became abnormally suspicious and moody, he was good-natured and jocular, though quick-tempered. He always justified his outlawry on the alleged ground that he had been driven into it by persecution. Doubtless, given the treatment of former Confederate soldiers by Unionists in the post-war Reconstruction period, Jesse’s claim was not completely imaginary.[I] In fact, corrupt, post-war Republican administrations[II] pushed other young men into outlawry, notably William Bonney, otherwise known as “Billy the Kid”. (Jacobsen, 1997)[III]
His father, Robert James, was a farmer and Baptist minister from
Kentucky who helped found William Jewell College in Liberty, Missouri. Robert James traveled to California to prospect for gold and died there when Jesse was three years old. After his father’s death, his mother Zerelda remarried, first to Benjamin Simms, and then to a doctor named Reuben Samuel. After their marriage in 1855, Samuel moved into the James home. In the tumultuous years leading up to the American Civil War, Zerelda and Reuben acquired a total of seven slaves and had them grow tobacco on their well-appointed farm. In addition to Jesse’s older brother, Alexander Franklin “Frank” James and younger sister Susan Lavenia James, Jesse gained four half-sibling: Sarah Louisa Samuel (Sarah Ellen), John Thomas Samuel, Fannie Quantrill Samuel, and Archie Peyton Samuel. Sarah later married a man named John C. Harmon. The James farm was visited in 1863 by Federal troops looking for information regarding Confederate guerrilla groups. The soldiers beat young Jesse and hanged his stepfather (who survived). BloodyBillAnderson Shortly after that, in 1864, Jesse joined a guerrilla unit led by Bloody Bill Anderson, who led the Centralia Massacre. Jesse joined at about the same time Anderson’s group split from Quantrill’s Raiders, so there is some uncertainty regarding whether Jessie James ever served under Quantrill.
The end of the Civil War left
Missouri in shambles. The pro-Union Republicans took control of the state government keeping the Democrats from voting or holding public office. Jesse James was shot in cold blood by Union militia when he attempted to surrender after the war’s end, leaving him badly wounded. His first cousin, Zerelda “Zee” Mimms (named after Jesse’s mother, so James called her “Zee”), nursed him back to health, and he started a nine-year courtship with her. She eventually became his wife. Meanwhile, some of Jesse’s old war comrades, led by Archie Clement, another of the bushwhacker leaders once allied with Quantrill, refused to return to a peaceful life.
In 1866, this group conducted the first armed robbery of a
US bank in post-civil war times, holding up the Clay County Savings Association in the town of Liberty. During this raid, Jesse deliberately shot a by standing student of William Jewell College. (See Wellman, 1961). The only reason Jesse robbed the bank was to get back the deed to his land. The gang staged several more robberies over the next few years, though state authorities (and local lynch mobs) had decimated the ranks of the older bushwhackers.
In 1868, Frank and Jesse James joined Cole Younger in robbing a bank at
Russellville, Kentucky. Jesse did not become famous, however, until December 1969 [1869], when he and Frank robbed the Daviess County Savings Association in Gallatin, Missouri. The robbery netted little, but James (it appears) shot and killed the cashier, mistakenly believing the man to be Samuel P. Cox, , the militia officer who killed “Bloody Bill” Anderson during the Civil War. The Liberty (MO) Tribune of December 17, 1869 tells the story of the James’ brothers narrow escape from one Sheriff Thomason. The robbery marked James’s emergence as the most famous of the former guerrillas turned outlaw, and it started an alliance with John Newman Edwards, a Kansas City Times editor who was campaigning to return the old Confederates to power in Missouri. Edwards published Jesse’s letters and made him into a symbol of Rebel defiance of Reconstruction through his elaborate editorials and supportive reporting. Jesse James’ own role in creating his rising public profile is debated by historians and biographers, though politics certainly surrounded his outlaw career and enhanced his notoriety.
ColeYoungerAfterNorthfieldRaid Meanwhile, the James brothers, along with Cole Younger and his brothers, Bob and Jim, Clell Miller and other former Confederates – now constituting the James-Younger Gang – continued a remarkable string of robberies from Iowa to Texas, and from Kansas to West Virginia. They robbed banks, stagecoaches and a fair in
Kansas City, often in front of large crowds, even hamming it up for the bystanders. In 1873, they turned to train robbery, derailing the Rock Island train in Adair, Iowa. Their later train robberies had a lighter touch – in fact only twice in all of Jesse James’ train hold-ups did he rob passengers, because he typically limited himself to the express safe in the baggage car. Such techniques fostered the Robin Hood image that Edwards was creating in his newspapers. Jesse James is thought to have shot 15 people during his bandit career.
The notoriety of the James brothers brought many attempts to bring them to justice. The Governor of
Missouri posted a reward of $1,000 each “…for the arrest and delivery of Jesse James and Frank James.” Express companies turned to the Pinkerton National Detective Agency in 1874 to stop the James-Younger Gang. The Chicago-based agency worked primarily against urban professional criminals as well as targeting unions and breaking strikes. The former guerrillas, supported by many old Confederates in Missouri, proved to be too much for them. One agent (Joseph Whicher) was dispatched to infiltrate Zerelda Samuel’s farm and turned up dead shortly afterward, with all but his hands eaten by the hogs that freely roamed the area. Two others, Louis J. Lull and John Boyle, were sent after the Youngers; Lull was killed by two of the Youngers in a roadside gunfight on March 17, 1874, though he killed John Younger before he died (an event depicted in the film, The Long Riders (1980).
AllanPinkerton_1817 Allan Pinkerton, the agency’s founder and leader, took on the case as a personal vendetta. Working with old Unionists around Jesse James’ family farm, he staged a raid on the homestead on the night of January 25, 1875. An incendiary device thrown inside by the detectives exploded[IV], killing James’ young half-brother and blowing off one of James’ mother’s arms. Afterward, Pinkerton denied that the raid’s intent was to burn the house down. However, a 1994 book written by Robert Dyer entitled Jesse James and the Civil War in Missouri (ISBN-13: 0826209597) contains the following:
“In early 1991, a Jesse James researcher named Ted Yeatman found an interesting letter among the papers of the Pinkerton Detective Agency. The letters was written by Allan Pinkerton to a lawyer working for him in
Liberty, Missouri, named Samuel Hardwicke. In the letter Pinkerton tells Hardwicke that when the men go to the James home to look for Jesse they should find some way to ‘burn the house down.’ He suggests they use some type of firebomb.”
This letter illustrates just how far Pinkerton was willing to go in his vendetta against the James brothers, but the move backfired. The bloody fiasco did more than all of Edwards’ columns to turn Jesse James into a sympathetic figure for much of the public. A bill that lavishly praised the James and Younger brothers and offered them amnesty was only narrowly defeated in the state legislature. Former Confederates, allowed to vote and hold office again, voted a limit on reward offers the governor could make for fugitives.
Jesse and his first cousin, Zerelda “Zee” Mimms married on
April 24, 1874, and had four children: Jesse James, Jr. (b. 1875), Gould James (b. 1878), Montgomery James (b. 1878), and Mary Susan James (b. 1879). Twins Gould and Montgomery died in infancy. His surviving son was raised by his mother to become a lawyer, and he spent his career as a respected member of the Kansas City, Missouri, bar. On September 7, 1876, the James-Younger gang attempted their most daring raid to date, on the First National Bank of Northfield, Minnesota. Cole and Bob Younger later stated that they selected the bank because of its connection to two Union generals and Radical Republican politicians. Adelbert Ames, the governor of Mississippi during Reconstruction, and Benjamin Butler, Ames’ father-in-law and the stern Union commander in occupied New Orleans. However, the gang had been casing other locations in the area as well.
The robbery was thwarted when Assistant Cashier Joseph Lee Heywood, left in charge while the bank officers attended the Philadelphia Centennial Exposition, refused to open the safe, falsely claiming that it was secured by a time lock even as they held a bowie knife to his throat and cracked his skull with a pistol butt. Unbeknownst to the gang, the vault was unprotected at the time of the robbery, the inner door closed but unlocked. Meanwhile, the citizens of
Northfield had taken notice of the robbery and were arriving with guns.[V] Before leaving the bank, Frank James shot the unarmed Heywood in the head. When the bandits exited the bank, they found the rest of their gang dead or wounded amid a hail of gunfire. Suspicious townsmen had confronted the bandits, ran to get their arms, and fired from under the cover of windows and the corners of buildings. The gang barely escaped, leaving two of their number and two unarmed townspeople (Heywood and a Swedish immigrant) dead in Northfield. A massive manhunt ensued. The James brothers eventually split from the others and escaped to Missouri. The Youngers and on other bandit, Charlie Pitts, were soon discovered. A brisk gunfight left Pitts dead and the Youngers all prisoners. Except for Frank and Jesse James, the James-Younger Gang was destroyed.
Jesse and Frank went to the Nashville, Tennessee area, where they went by the names of Thomas Howard and B.J. Woodson, respectively. Frank seemed to settle down, but Jesse remained restless. He recruited a new gang in 1879 and returned to crime, holding up a train at
Glendale, Missouri, on October 8, 1879. The robbery began a spree of crimes, including the hold-up of the federal paymaster of a canal project in Muscle Shoals, Alabama, and two more train robberies. But the new gang did not consist of old, battle-hardened guerillas; they soon turned against each other or were captured, while James grow paranoid, killing one gang member and frightening another away. The authorities grew suspicious, and by 1881 the brothers were forced to return to Missouri. In December, Jesse rented a house in Saint Joseph, Missouri, not far from where he had been born and raised. Frank, however, decided to move to safer territory, heading east to Virginia.
With his gang depleted by arrests, deaths and defections, Jesse thought he had only two men left whom he could trust: brothers Bob and Charley Ford. Charley had been out on raids with Jesse before, but Bob was an eager new recruit. To better protect himself, Jesse asked the Ford brothers to move in with him and his family. Little did he know that Bob Ford had been conducting secret negotiations with Thomas T. Crittenden, the
Missouri governor, to bring in Jesse James. Crittenden had made the capture of the James brothers his top priority; in his inaugural address he declared that no political motives could be allowed to keep them from justice. Barred by law from offering a sufficiently large reward, he had turned to the railroad and express corporations to put up a $10,000 bounty for each of them.
The assassination proved a national sensation. The Fords made no attempt to hide their role. As crowds pressed into the little house in
St. Joseph to see the dead bandit, they surrendered to the authorities, pleaded guilty, were sentenced to hang. However, they were promptly pardoned by the governor. Indeed, the governor’s quick pardon suggested that he was well aware that the brothers intended to kill, rather than capture, Jesse James. … The implication that the chief executive of Missouri conspired to kill a private citizen startled the public and helped create a new legend in James.
CloseUp_JesseJames_dead The Fords received a portion of the reward (some of it also went to law enforcement officials in the plan) and fled
Missouri. Zerelda, Jesse’s mother, appeared at the coroner’s inquest, deeply anguished, and loudly denounced Dick Liddil, a former gang member who was cooperating with state authorities. Charley Ford committed suicide in May 1884. Bob Ford was later killed by a shotgun blast to the throat in his tent saloon in Creede, Colorado, on June 8, 1892. His killer, Edward Capehart O’Kelley, was sentenced to life in prison. Because of his health problems, his sentence was commuted, and O’Kelley was released on October 3, 1902.
Jesse James’ epitaph, selected by his mother, reads: In Loving Memory of my Beloved Son, Murdered by a Traitor and Coward Whose Name is not Worthy to Appear Here. …
During his lifetime, Jesse James was largely celebrated by former Confederates, to whom he appealed directly in his letters to the press. Indeed, some historians credit him with contributing to the rise of Confederates to dominance in
Missouri politics (by the 1880s, for example, both U.S. Senators from the state had been identified with the Confederate cause). His return to crime after the fall of Reconstruction, however, was devoid of political overtones, but it helped cement his place in American memory as a simple but remarkable effective bandit. During the Populist and Progressive eras, he emerged as America’s Robin Hood, standing up against corporations in defense of the small farmer … This image is still seen in films, as well as songs and folklore. …

This part of the Wikipedia entry deals with the consensus that Jesse James was not killed on that day in St. Joseph, Missouri but someone else in his place …

Rumors of Jesse James’ survival proliferated almost as soon as the newspapers announced his death. Some said that Ford did not kill James but someone else, in an elaborate plot to allow him to escape justice. Some stories say he lived in Guthrie, Oklahoma, as late as 1948, and a man named J. Frank Dalton, who claimed to be Jesse James, died in Granbury, Texas, in 1951 at age 103. Some stories claim the real recipient of Ford’s bullet was a man named Charles Bigelow, reported to have been living with James’ wife at the time. Generally speaking, however, these tales received little credence, then or now; Jesse’s wife, Zee, died alone and in poverty. The body buried in Missouri as Jesse James was exhumed in 1995 and, according to a report by Anne C. Stone, Ph.D., James E. Starrs, L.L.M; and Mark Stoneking, Ph.D. titled Mitochondrial DNA Analysis of the Presumptive Remains of Jesse James, does appear to be the remains of Jesse James. A court order was granted in 2000 to exhume and test Dalton’s body, but the wrong body was exhumed. Some people believed that Jesse James hid in the attic of a two story house in Dublin, Texas while he was hiding from the law.

Now the story of J. Frank Dalton who claimed he was Jesse James …

JFrankDalton-01 J. Frank Dalton stated in his application for a Confederate veteran’s pension that he had been born in Goliad, Texas and had served as a Confederate irregular with William C. Quantrill. But he also liked to claim that he was the famous US Marshall Frank Dalton, who had been killed in a gunfight with many witnesses in 1887. Dalton would later change his story and claim he was the noted Jesse James.
Beginning in 1949, J. Frank Dalton’s story was promoted and encouraged by the proprietors of Meramec Caverns (“Jesse James ‘Hideout’) near
Stanton, Missouri. Henry J. Walker later wrote a book supporting Dalton’s claims, calling it Jesse James “the Outlaw” (1961)
No historian has ever taken
Dalton’s claims seriously, and his knowledge of details the real Jesse would have been aware of was notably lacking. Dalton’s claim is often connected to a tale of hidden gold and a plot to revive the Confederacy in the years after the Civil War. Homer Croy, who knew the James family and had interviewed members of Jesse’s gang, ridiculed Dalton in his book Jesse James Was My Neighbor. Croy wrote that he once asked Jesse James Jr if any of his alleged fathers had even come to visit them. Jesse Jr, who sometimes played a cowboy in silent films, smiled and replied, “Not a one.”
In an attempt to put an end to the dispute, the body buried in
Missouri as Jesse James was exhumed in 1995 and the DNA analysis resulted in a 99.7% probability that they were indeed those of the outlaw. Still unwilling to accept this, Dalton’s proponents got a court order in 2000 to exhume and test Dalton’s body to solve the mystery “once and for all.” Unfortunately, the wrong body was exhumed, and Dalton’s remains have yet to be tested.

But the question is, if Jesse James wasn’t assassinated, who was buried in his place? Why did Zerelda, Jesse’s mother, wail over the body? Why did she insist that her son be buried on the farm instead of the James family plot four miles up the road in Kearney? Was it truly out of fear of grave robbers or souvenir hunters? Answers seem to pop up with more questions following them.

J. Frank Dalton claimed that a man named Charles (“Charlie”) Bigelow was killed in a plot to allow Jesse to escape his life as an outlaw.

Charlie Bigelow was from the town named after his father and he had ridden with the James gang for a short period and then left to rob on his own. Charlie Bigelow resembled Jesse James and committed some robberies assuming the famous outlaw’s identity, which initiated the idea of the assassination plan.

Identifying scars and marks on Jesse James are listed in several accounts of the life of Jesse James: an index finger with the tip missing on his left hand caused by an accidental discharge of a revolver during Jesse’s youth; rope burns from Union soldiers hanging him from the barn rafters to abstract information as to the whereabouts of his brother, Frank, and others involved in guerrilla raids. Photos compared with Jesse James ears and J. Frank Dalton’s ears also were used to compare.

Historians tried to find out if Charles Bigelow truly existed, but there is no record of him anywhere in the historical records of St. Joseph.

In J. Frank Dalton’s discussion of his supposed Jesse James’ youth, he was asked who taught him to ride a horse. His answer was “his father.”

This would be impossible because his father died when he was four years of age.

But it is no wonder that these rumors or stories of the possibility that Jesse Woodson James was actually the one buried in Missouri.

When Jesse James was exhumed in 1902, by the request of Zerelda James at the farmhouse so it could be put in the James family plot in Mt. Olivet Cemetery in Kearney, four miles from the farm, the body was examined.

Examination of the skull showed a bullet hole in the back of the head, but no evidence of an exit hole. Reports from 1882 stated that Bob Ford shot Tom Howard with a .44-caliber bullet, that the bullet went through the skull and embedded in the wall. Yet, a .38-caliber bullet was found in Jesse James coffin.

In 1995, the James family exhumed (once again) the body buried at Mt. Olive Cemetery in Kearney, Missouri under the tombstone of Jesse James. DNA testing was performed in a laboratory. When the coffin was opened, authorities found the body was lying face down, which had probably occurred when Zee had moved the body of her son from the farm in 1902. The bones in the grave were deteriorated from water, so people claim that the DNA testing was inconclusive.

At the website, The Outlaws, the story is told concerning the 1995 exhumation …

The real problem with the 1995 exhumation and Mitochondrial DNA testing is that the chain of evidence is not from the grave. Professor of Law and Forensic Sciences James E. Starrs of George Washington University in Washington, D.C. did the test. Since no bones or teeth from the grave could be used, he got Judge Vic Howard to order the tooth encased in the Tupperware container in 1978 at the James Farm to be exhumed. When the container was unearthed, it was discovered that the tooth that was supposed to be there was missing! … The results of the 1995 exhumation and DNA testing proved one thing and only one thing: Nothing. …
It is true that the tooth and hair used in the DNA test definitely came from a James family member, but which family member? No one knows. …
There are other problems with the 1995 exhumation, too. Remains exhumed in 1978 from the original grave of Jesse James revealed a 34 to 42 year old Caucasian who died from 100 to 150 years ago and had noticeable dental problems. The 1995 exhumation gave the height as between 5 feet 8 inches and 5 feet 10 inches. The bullet found in the 1995 exhumation was not believed to be the one which killed him. When Jesse was trying to surrender at the end of the Civil War, he was shot from a 1851 Colt Navy Revolver, a common sidearm used during and after the Civil War, and there exists a report that a bullet he received was not recovered by the doctor who treated him, so the bullet found in the grave could have been this bullet. …yet where was the .45-caliber bullet that was claimed to be the fatal bullet fired by Bob Ford …? Further, Jesse did not use tobacco products, yet the man in the grave certainly did. The teeth examined from the 1995 exhumation showed that they were corroded and heavily stained from tobacco use. It would appear that the man buried on the James farm in 1882 and the man exhumed in 1995 was the same man, but he could not possibly be Jesse James.

To add to more confusion, it is believed by a person named Betty Dorsett Duke who she claims her relative, James L. Courtney was the real Jesse James. [See website]. Betty Duke’s research and story is more believable than the story of J. Frank Dalton – and the argument continues. A future Myth Blaster article will examine Betty Duke’s research and claim that her relative, Mr. Courtney, was Jesse James from Missouri.

Another version of the incident of the Missouri anti-slavery militia, but this site has no references

In June 1863, a squad rode into the yard of the farm and accused Reuben Samuel of being disloyal to the cause and hiding guerrilla troops. They bound his hands behind his back, looped a noose over his head, and hung him from a nearby coffee tree. They hoisted hum up and down, trying to get him to say where Frank and the Rangers were hiding. Gasping for breath, Dr. Samuel said nothing, so the group tied one end of the rope to the tree trunk and left him dangling, choking to death. They then found Zerelda, who was five months pregnant with Fannie, and tried to make her talk. When she refused, they threw her across the room in a wall. The soldiers next went looking for Jesse. They found him plowing a field and immediately surrounded him, demanding to know Frank’s whereabouts. When they realized he would not cooperate, they drove him through the corn rows, lashing his back with a rope so severely that it was crisscrossed with bloody welts, and his shirt hung in bloody tatters. He crawled home, where he found his mother trying to revive her husband. Zerelda had managed to cut Dr. Samuel down, but he suffered brain damage from the incident and would later have to be institutionalized. …

Myth Blaster Verdict: Inconclusive, more likely that James L. Courtney was Jesse James than J. Frank Dalton of Texas, if one is to believe that it is not Jesse James that was buried on the James farm. A film (The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford) released this year starring Brad Pitt and Casey Affleck proves the fascination of the legend of Jesse James still continues. Until proven otherwise, history books will continue to print the assassination story as the demise of the legendary outlaw. Probably the best evidence that the person in the grave in Missouri is not Jesse James is the articles and book written by Betty Dorsett Duke, who claims that her grandfather who was living under an assumed name of James L. Courtney was the legendary Jesse James. (See Betty’s listed link below). Maybe this argument will never be solved as time goes on and DNA forensic evidence gets more impossible to make a conclusion.

In summary, I guess that it is up to the reader whether or not they believe that Jesse James was assassinated or he lived to die in old age with an assumed name and a new life. One can wonder, on a personal note, how Zee James, Jesse’s wife, could have wrote off her husband without the chance of seeing him again. Forthcoming will be an overall picture of Jesse James – his biography, the people that surrounded him and his family, as well as the remarkable possibility that James L. Courtney was really Jesse James and an unknown person lies in the grave in Kearney, Missouri. It is said that Zee James died in poverty, but then she made money providing public tours of the James farm, along with Frank James according to records. Confusing piece of history? You bet. Jesse must be laughing wherever he may be. Historians and Wild West buffs have been arguing about this for decades, to include the legend that Billy the Kid didn’t die at the hands of Pat Garrett. More to come when I spotlight on the biography and background of Jesse James, the gang and the family, as well as two men who were supposed to be Jesse James incognito in Texas. Stay tuned.

Sources and Further Reading:

Bone Hunter by Amanda Ripley, Washington City, 1998
Chronology of Jesse James by Floyd D.P. Oydegaard
James L. Courtney by Betty Dorsett Duke
Betty Dorsett Duke’s article and Book About Jesse James
Profile of Dr. James Starrs – Forensic Science
Pinkerton National Detective AgencyWikipedia
Federal Bureau of Investigation – Jesse James File
Jesse James Buried in Granbury, Texas by Gary Hancock
Dime Novels – Stanford University
Jesse James Was My Neighbor by Homer Croy (eBay book sale)


[I] This segment does not mention the fact that at 16 years old, he was taken to the family barn or out in the cornfield and strung up with rope by his neck, beating him with the rope, and possible burning the bottom of his feet, to get information about the whereabouts of Confederate guerillas. He had a rope burn scar on his neck for the rest of his life from that treatment and burns marks on his feet, according to the autopsy report. Whether or not the torture worked and he gave them information is not known or that it was just Jesse’s stepfather that was tortured with rope is not clear. Other body marks: alleged bullet wounds to the amount of 33, as well as the tip of his index finger (second finger from the thumb) missing because of a firearm discharge accident when he was young or during the Civil War.

[II] An offshoot of the Republican Party of Abraham Lincoln called the Radical Republicans.

[III] Billy the Kid lived in an area that was not infiltrated by carpetbaggers and Radical Republicans; however, he was pushed into going on a shooting spree after his benefactor, an English immigrant rancher was murdered in cold blood by the local outlaws that were friends or employees of the corrupt town businessman. See William Bonney.

[IV] The agents claimed it was only a “smoker” bomb and accidentally rolled into the fireplace which caused it to explode.

[V] In those days the banks did not have federal depository insurance where the people’s money would be reimbursed after a robbery, therefore, bank robbers were not just stealing from a bank as a business entity, but from the local people themselves.

The URI to TrackBack this entry is: http://lighthousepatriotjournal.wordpress.com/2007/09/12/myth-blaster-was-jesse-james-assassinated-or-die-of-old-age/trackback/

RSS feed for comments on this post.

21 Comments Leave a comment.

  1. My son just sent me the link to your site which I read with great interest. I like the way you examine the various stories before making your final determination of whether or not which is truth or myth. Keep up the good work.

    Respectfully,

    Betty Dorsett Duke

    http://www.thetruthaboutjessejamesintexas.com

  2. Jesse was killed in 1882. End of story!

  3. Edward B:
    Thanks for sharing your thoughts; however, you are going to have to come up with a better, sourced rebuttal than that.

  4. The proof is in the DNA. The grave was opened several years ago and DNA tests were done. It would be fun to think that Jesse lived on. But the DNA tests prove he did not. J. Frank Dalton was an old man that wanted to be famous before he died and in 1950, there was really no way to determine without a doubt that he “might” be who he claimed. However, today is differant. We can prove the facts and the fact is that Dalton was nothing more than an old man wanting to claim he was Jesse. Sorry, but that blows all the myths out of the water as far as I’m concerned. By the way…you’ve got a great website and I really do enjoy reading it. Keep up the good work.

  5. Edward Bogard:
    Someone, a technician or whoever, messed up the DNA test and made it invalid. And you left out several important pieces of physical evidence and documented evidence – certain scars and a missing tip of his right forefinger – and certified affidavits.
    Thanks for stopping by and sharing your thoughts.
    K

  6. For the most part, people tend to want to believe in extraordinarily outlandish possibilities: Elivs lives, Tupac faked his death, etc. We are so quick to deceive ourselves. The truth of the matter: Jesse James was shot dead in 1882. Despite the apparent scrutiny, a DNA match, statistically speaking, is largely unquestionable. Period. The mere suggestion of the possibility of a cover-up is at best lightly amusing…However, it also strikes me as a sheisty avenue for certain individuals to capitalize (book sales, etc) on the sheer ingnorance of fools enthralled by their own sweet-but-senseless romantic notions. Bob Ford, hypnotized as he was, made a mistake on that fateful morning, now so long ago…Let us (now) not make our own, and in turn, let a legend–let Jesse–rest in peace.

  7. I feel the underlying need to make one or two more comments…First of all, in direct reference to the following quote from a previous post: “Someone, a technician or whoever, messed up the DNA test and made it invalid”…Oh, c’mon, are we talking O.J. Simpson here?…Actuality precedes potentiality (a rule our man, Jesse James, seemed to live by) Prove it.
    And please direct me to these “certified affidavits” that “prove” something (anything) with a genuine measure of validity. I am reminded of someone who told me that Jesse’s corpse was–undoubtedly–an imposter…Based soley on the fact that his mother, after faking her tears, chose not to bury it within the James’ family plot…and if I bury my cat in my neighbors’ garden, it must also have been their own.

  8. J. Tensing:
    Thanks for sharing your thoughts and opinion ..,
    In regards to your “need to make one or two more comments”.
    That is what this is all about – discussion.
    First, let me give you an inside fact – back in the 1970s, I traveled through the areas where the James Gang operated and, as a side interest while investigating Belle Shirley, historically known in fact and folklore as “Belle Starr” to provide research for a manuscript I was writing in the form of an historical novel. In so doing, I ran across this information concerning Jesse James. I have wanted to write a “Part Two” to this article, but haven’t done so as of yet. The point here is this: neither has it been proven true or proven false; however, the affidavits by the investigators who started this and interviewed the elderly gentleman who was in a retirement home as a Confederate veteran (few had been alive then) had more significant evidence in the form of physical scars, affidavits signed by people interviewed that was still alive to remember or had been some part of that historical outlaw’s life in some way to provide some substance to the old Confederate’s tale. AS time went by and DNA came into the picture, difficulties arose in the DNA testing. This would be the only thing that would either prove that Jesse was the one who was presumably shot by his own cousins (the Ford brothers) or a person who had been making people believe he was Jesse James when he committed several breaches of law.
    And, I suggest you read the “About” section – that clearly states the rules of rebuttals: Provide sources and references to your research that you base you rebuttal on. Stating that you refuse to believe something is nothing but opinion, and as you accuse here – based upon no fact.
    I have presented this article objectively and also presented some interests that it deserves.
    With that in mind, please feel free to comment on this article or any other one here. In fact, I welcome it. There is more to this e-journal than “Myth Blaster” articles, just take a peep at the subject categories and click on one that interests you. It will bring up all articles to date that are under that subject heading (all articles have at least two categories).
    Thanks for stopping by – looking forward to intellectual discussion in the future.
    PS – Those affidavits you ridicule are legal documents and in historical record files. Check it out. One person who owned the Jesse James Historical Museum actually offered $25,000 to any person who could prove that his research was in error or that the real Jesse James lived to be over 100 years old. I think he was serious. Also on display were the records, photos and physical evidence presented in his argument. If you think this whole thing was based on “faking tears” via his mother (and wife), then you need to do a bit more reading and research.
    Best Regards …
    KAL

  9. J. Tensing:
    Further comment …
    This article contains 5,042 words, so it may be that you missed the part of my conclusion and the “Myth Blaster Verdict” – which remains, inconclusive. Without DNA evidence, it will remain so.
    The physical evidence of the Dalton gentleman was more conclusive that the other person claiming her relative was the “real Jesse James”. Since “Dalton” had no living relatives, except friends and associates of J. James, in the photo you see them visiting him in the last days before his death. Wacky made up yarn by a senile gentleman or maybe certain memories are fuzzy because of his age? The physical marks were:
    (a) Tip of forefinger (can’t remember if left hand or right hand) missing – because Jesse James in his youth shot it off in a misfire accident with a pistol.
    (b) Rope burn scars – caused by the Union soldiers looking for members of the Quantrill Confederate riders who had used a rope to string him up (about 16 years of age) and strangle-tortured him to try to get information about Quantrill and his brother, Frank. Jesse soon after joined the Quantrill group, mostly in his hatred for the Yankee soldiers that gave him the neck scars caused by the rope abrasion action.
    I wish I had the old research file when I had accumulated all this information with more physical evidence details, but it, along with personal value items were lost in a flood when the basement of my father’s house had about two feet of water for several days until the sump pump was repaired. It saddens me because it represented a lot of work to obtain copies of the records, photos and anything else I could get my hands on. Although, the final evidence would be an accurate DNA test, but it looks like this won’t happen anytime soon or when the Jesse James lineage disappears from discovery.
    KAL

  10. What isn’t discussed is J. Frank Dalton’s work with a St. Louis newspaper. He
    wrote about the James gang and knew many details about robberies from his own
    research. It is very unlikely he was Jesse James or Charlie Bigelow. It isn’t even
    known for certain that he was J. Frank Dalton. He wrote a section called “Outlawry
    in Missouri” in Governor Crittenden’s memoirs under the name J. Frank Dalton.
    Incidentally, there’s some good information on Quantrill’s final days in my new
    book “Confederate Guerrilla Sue Mundy,” published by McFarland Publishers
    of Jefferson, North Carolina.
    Regards, Thomas Shelby Watson, Taylorsville, Ky.

  11. Zee James was mentioned as having the body of Jesse exhumed in 1902–SHE DIED IN 1900 get your facts straight…. Zerelda his mother had his body removed and she died in 1911. Like to see the facts printed.

  12. Ida:
    Thanks for your input, but the confusion is because Zeralda was both the name of mother and wife, and James called his wife “Zee”. I made the change in one sentence.
    “Straight” enough for you?

  13. From 1989 to 1992, I was married to the 6th cousin of Jesse James. Jesse’s 4th cousin lived (or lives~I haven’t talked to my ex-husband in years) in Owosso, Michigan. She had original wanted posters, saddle, spurs, guns and holsters that belonged to Jesse. From what my ex said, her grandson~his 6th cousin, she wasn’t going to put any of it in her will. She was just gonna let all of the kids have a free-for-all when she passed! My ex-father-in-law and his family lived in Saginaw County, Michigan, the last time I saw them. I spoke with the family regarding their famous outlaw history. The family members that I spoke with, remembered when Jesse would come to Michigan and hideout in the barns. They told me that Jesse was a much older man when he came up here. They were VERY adamant about the fact that Jesse James was not shot in the back of the head and killed. Of course, I was a bit sceptical. They did produce a document that was signed by a hired private investigator. It was about 19 years ago that I saw the document. I do remember that the document was in a photo album, is yellow, was officially signed and dated to verify the document, and was in the posession of my ex-father-in-law. The document claimed that Jesse James died a natural death of old age, here in Michigan, and stated where the unmarked grave is located~~in Saginaw County, Michigan. This is the family story that has been passed down through their family and was told to me. My maiden name is Shelby. The subject of Jesse James came up one time when I was with my Grandfather. He told me that my family came over on the ships, from Wales, England. I was told that my great-great-great uncle had a wife and a bunch of “mean” boys. Those bad-boys ended up riding with another bunch of bad-boys~~the James boys. They would rob banks and trains together. There is also a story of jars of money being buried, with a fence post being the marker. Wish I knew where!

    The previous is a true account of what was told to me by both the Shelby and the James families.

    Honestly and Sincerely,

    Robin
    Saginaw, Michigan

  14. Robin SH:
    Thanks for sharing this information.
    It might be noted that Jesse was shot in the back (three times) and not the head, according to the Merremec-produced records of autopsy, and yet the quoted transcript says the back of the head. Death images of Jesse’s body on display shows no exit wound in the forehead. Whether the caliber was a .38 or .44, at such a close range, if Jesse was shot in the back of the head, the bullet would have gone through his skull and splattered his brains on the wall through a nasty exit wound.
    Many various tales have surfaced concerning this hero-outlaw. I doubt that there is any money around to be have been buried. After dividing the share of loot, most outlaws spent it quickly. And, I believe that it was Jesse James that was buried in the late 1800s. It was well-known how much he cared for his family – why would he assume another name and leave forever his wife and children in poverty?
    Of all the historical figures concerning the American Wild West, Jesse James is probably the most known, and not just in America.
    Your participation via commentary is appreciated.

  15. As a writer, I always find it helpful having a second set of eyes proof my work. It would seem your interesting article could use some extensive editing. For instance, there is a typo in the sentence: “Jesse did not become famous, however, until December 1969″.
    I believe that should probably read “1869″.
    Another sentence doesn’t make sense and appears as a possible copying error.
    “The robbery netted little, but James (it appears) shot and killed the cashier, mistakenly believing the man to be Samuel P. Cox, the militia officer who killed the cashier, mistakenly believing the man to be Samuel P. Cox, the militia officer who killed “Bloody Bill” Anderson during the Civil War.”
    Who killed which cashier? I know what you mean, James supposedly killed the cashier believing him to be Cox, the person that killed Anderson.

    There are a few more errors however, I believe you get my point.

    One thing we all know for certain – Jessie James is dead.

  16. I stand to be corrected. I was thinking over the information on your site, while I was typing my information. Also, like I said, “There is also a story of jars of money being buried, with a fence post being the marker.”. All I know is that the James family swore up and down that and were extremely serious about what was told to me. Looking at their very serious faces as they told me their tales, I tend to believe most of what was told. I just told it as I remember them telling it to me. If they were just telling tales, then over 20 people have the gift of telling tales without visibly giving any sign that they are doing so. As Rodman said in his post, “One thing we all know for certain – Jessie James is dead.”.

  17. Rodman:
    Thanks for your commentary.
    The sentence “Jesse did not become famous, however, until December 1969″ comes from the quoted text, therefore that “typo” is not mine. I have put in brackets within the quote, the correct date. Thanks.
    The next error is mine – it has been changed to read:
    The robbery netted little, but James (it appears) shot and killed the cashier, mistakenly believing the man to be Samuel P. Cox, , the militia officer who killed “Bloody Bill” Anderson during the Civil War.
    I proofed what I wrote, it seems, better than the quoted words. When the information is obtained from the Internet, I have, since then, used copy-and-paste method, to ensure no “typos” occur.
    Thanks for your intellectual observation and objective corrections.
    Yes, whether Jesse James lived long after the alleged slaying or whatever his alias is – the man is definitely dead. Just some interesting discussion about a controversial American “hero” outlaw, who was a product of their times and subject material of that periods Dime Novels.
    AS you can see from my analysis, the argument seems to go on forever whether Jesse James was the one shot dead in his home, et cetera.
    Thanks for taking the time to comment and stop by …
    KAL

  18. Robin:
    In the case of the many tales of Jesse, there is no need to apologize for any errors, et cetera. When information is passed by word of mouth, often the original story is changed somehow, and folks just relate what they are told. I didn’t mean to question anyone’s integrity in your family, and they were only relating what they were told. While it is unlikely, there could have been a jar of money hidden to be retrieved later and Jesse or one of his gang never got the opportunity to retrieve it. That is a shame for his surviving wife and children because of their economic situation. At least they had a home and some land paid for to live on.
    Real people in history who, who become heroes or infamous, often have legends intertwined among the facts. I believe the writers of the Dime Novels in those days to entertain the folks back East and other places in the world, about the Wild West and their desire to sell copies of the literature contributed a lot to the exaggeration of the people who lived (and died) in those days.
    Thanks for sharing your thoughts and memories passed down through your family.

  19. Rodman:
    Thanks for addressing the errors and your understanding as a writer.
    The correction has been made concerning the date and the dysfunctional sentence. The sentence is to read:
    The robbery netted little, but James (it appears) shot and killed the cashier, mistakenly believing the man to be Samuel P. Cox, the militia officer who killed ‘Bloody Bill’ Anderson during the Civil War.”
    Thanks for taking the time to comment and stopping by for a visit.

  20. I think the part about James Courtney being Jesse James that is hard to swallow is that Courtney was 6′4″. Jesse James was never described as being that tall, and that would have been really tall in the 19th century.

  21. Good point, Mark


Leave a Comment